Sunlit reading corner with an oatmeal chair, wool throw and white baseboard heat beneath a window overlooking a late-autumn Pocono backyard.

Who Gets the Fuel in the Tank When a Bartonsville Home Sells?

"Any remaining heating and cooking fuels stored on the Property at the time of settlement." That phrase sits in the fixtures and personal property paragraph of the Pennsylvania Association of Realtors' standard agreement of sale. It appears in a list between trash compactors and solar panels.

For a Bartonsville home heated by oil or propane, the fuel in the tank can be worth hundreds of dollars.

Fuel in the agreement of sale

The agreement lists items for daily proration at settlement. In the edition PAR's Legal Hotline has explained to its members, the proration paragraph reads like this:

"At time of settlement, the following will be pro-rated on a daily basis between Buyer and Seller, reimbursing where applicable: current taxes; rents; interest on mortgage assumptions; condominium fees and homeowner association fees; water and/or sewer fees, together with any other lienable municipal service fees."

The Pennsylvania Association of Realtors discussed a disagreement over fuel in a Legal Hotline post on sellers demanding fuel costs at closing. Sellers pointed to the proration clause and asked buyers to pay a share of the last fill-up. Buyers pointed to the personal property paragraph.

PAR released its current Agreement of Sale in September 2025, and the only standard forms it has updated since are commercial ones. The safest habit is to read paragraph 7 of the exact form in front of you. PAR's own Agreement of Sale refresher from July 2025 says agents should read "every word" of that paragraph with every client, on every offer.

Why this comes up so often around Bartonsville

In plenty of suburban markets the question never comes up because the house is on a gas line. Monroe County is different. The Census Bureau's 2024 American Community Survey 5-year estimates count about 61,212 occupied homes in the county. Here's how they're heated:

Main heating fuel, Monroe County Homes Share
Electricity 28,426 about 46%
Fuel oil, kerosene 13,985 about 23%
Bottled or tank gas, such as propane 7,676 about 13%
Utility gas 6,037 about 10%
Wood 2,742 about 4%

That's about one home in three on oil or propane, and only about one in ten on piped gas. UGI lists Hamilton, Pocono and Stroud townships in its Gas–Central supply region, and its service footprint covers certificated portions of the counties it serves. Being inside a listed township doesn't mean a particular street has a gas main. If you're buying, ask what heats the house before you write the offer. If you're selling, know the answer before you list.

What's actually in the tank at today's prices

Fuel is worth enough to matter. The U.S. Energy Information Administration's Pennsylvania weekly heating oil and propane table shows these statewide residential averages, before taxes, for fall 2026:

Week of Residential heating oil, per gallon Residential propane, per gallon
October 5, 2026 $5.852 $3.130
October 19, 2026 $6.066 $3.175
November 2, 2026 $5.927 $3.311
November 9, 2026 $5.708 $3.332

At the November 9 price, 100 gallons of heating oil comes to about $571 before tax, and 100 gallons of propane to about $333. A seller who topped off in mid-October paid close to the season's high for oil. Propane has gone up every week since October 12, and the November 9 price is the highest in the table. EIA collects these prices weekly from October through March and updates the table every week.

These are statewide averages, not a local quote. To pin down the real number, ask for the seller's most recent delivery ticket and a tank gauge reading close to settlement.

Propane adds a wrinkle, because the tank may not belong to the seller

Oil tanks usually belong to the house. Propane tanks often belong to the propane company. In the agreement's list of included items, propane tanks are listed "if owned." A separate line tells the parties to contact the provider about items the seller doesn't own, with propane tanks given as an example.

PAR's Legal Hotline described a supplier that buys the remaining propane back from a selling homeowner, leaves it in the tank, and then offers to sell it to the buyer.

The tank lease is the second issue. PAR's July 2025 refresher says the agreement asks sellers to identify leased items such as propane tanks. PAR suggests buyer's agents ask for the leases before making an offer, and listing agents have them ready as early as possible.

Supplier policies on new accounts, leased tanks and leftover fuel vary. Ask the company named on the tank directly. Delivery companies around Bartonsville include PennyWise Fuel, based in Henryville, which delivers heating oil and propane from Stroudsburg to Milford and also installs propane tanks. A Plus Oil delivers residential heating oil to Stroudsburg, Mount Pocono and Tannersville.

If the oil tank is buried

A heating oil tank can sit in the basement or underground in the yard. The Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection's residential home heating oil page says leaks can cause property damage and environmental contamination, and can leave the owner liable. DEP recommends routine inspection, maintenance and repair, and links to self-inspection checklists. When an underground tank is taken out of service, DEP advises getting written quotes and inspecting the removed tank for holes or corrosion. If contamination is seen or suspected, it says to contact DEP.

For a buyer, a buried tank is one more reason to settle the fuel terms early. If the buyer's side wants the tank inspected or removed, that's best known before the offer is final, just like the gallons inside it. Our post on the township line Bartonsville buyers should check before the septic inspection covers the other underground system that tends to come up in the same week.

What to have on paper before anyone signs

  1. The fuel type. Know whether the house runs on oil, propane, electric, wood or a mix, and who supplies each.
  2. Tank ownership. Find out whether the propane tank is owned or leased. If it's leased, get a copy of the lease.
  3. The last delivery ticket. Have the date, the gallons and the price per gallon.
  4. Fuel in the tank. Ask about the gallons in the tank and the price per gallon.
  5. The tank's location. Know whether an oil tank is in the basement or underground.

Sellers who are getting ready to list can put this list next to the rest of their prep in how to get your Bartonsville home ready to sell. Buyers who are budgeting can add fuel to the costs covered in our Bartonsville property tax basics.

I'm a real estate agent, not an attorney or a tax or financial advisor. This post is general information, so please confirm what your exact signed agreement says about fuel with a qualified professional.

If you're selling a Bartonsville home on oil or propane this winter, or making an offer on one, I'll help you get the tank, the lease and the fuel terms into the agreement before it's signed. Reach out to Kacey Conaty and we'll start with the delivery ticket.

Work With Kacey

Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact Kacey today to discuss all your real estate needs!

Follow Me on Instagram